Afterwards, the band put out their biggest album to date, All The Right Reasons (2005) which produced 3 top 10 singles and 5 top 20 singles, on the Billboard Hot 100 example of songs like "Photograph", "Far Away", and "Rockstar".
The band went through a few drummer changes between 19, achieving its current lineup when Adair replaced drummer Ryan Vikedal.
Billboard ranks them the most successful rock group of the decade; their song "How You Remind Me" was listed as the best-selling rock song of the decade and the fourth best-selling of the decade.
Nickelback promptly went into the studio with their new drummer from January through May 2005. Also, the album peaked number 1 at the Canadian albums chart.
The sessions resulted in their fifth studio album, All the Right Reasons which was released on October 3, 2005. The album sold more than 12 million singles and over 9 million ringtones.
Although an unknown property in the industry at the time, the venue was packed out. I thought their song 'Leader of Men' was a smash hit." Off the stage he was impressed by their industry and initiative in managing their career.
Despite this, it still took Burman three months for him to convince his label bosses to approve the signing, a decision that would mark Roadrunner's first move into mainstream rock.
They were listed number seven on the Billboard top artist of the decade, with four albums listed on the Billboard top albums of the decade.
Then, the band's fourth album The Long Road (2003) spawned 5 singles and continued the band's mainstream success with their hit single "Someday" which peaked at number 7 on the Billboard Hot 100 and number 1 at the Canadian Singles Chart.
"Figured You Out" was also released as a single and topped the Mainstream Rock Charts for 13 consecutive weeks.
Just after New Year's Day 2005, drummer Ryan Vikedal was replaced by 3 Doors Down's drummer Daniel Adair.
It peaked number 1 on the Billboard 200 with 323,350 copies in its first week in the United States, as well as producing five U. Hot 100 top 20 singles: "Photograph", "Savin' Me", "Far Away", "If Everyone Cared" and "Rockstar". The album also made Nickelback the first band in Nielsen BDS history to have 5 singles on the CHR charts.